The Academy’s Weapon Replicator

Very good, got nothing much to say.

Characters aren't one dimensional and actually have their own plots going on—the side cast stand on their own and are rememberable, world building is nice and the protagonist is good as well, there's a overreaching plot to the story so it's not some random villain of the day stuff either. 

It's like Advent of the Three Calamities, but still different. 

The story is great

At first, MC is extremely weak, yet not only wins by precise strategies and trickery, but also slowly, he gets stronger, his growth is neither slow nor fast but balance

The story is mostly focus on mystery and different problems which can't be solve by strength, but it has action even though you might not see much of it at first

If you like a smart MC with creative methods then this is Definitely a MOST READ

Recommended! The story is awesome, the characters is on fire, main character is dang cool and I'm freaking hooked, waiting for more chapter!!

Boring, so many chapters have wasted on side characters interaction with no improvement on mc's replicator skill. It's frustrating. I got interested when he first shows his skill and replicate a weapon, after that the story focuses on how mc could get the game main characters on his side and the title was forgotten

TOTALLY UNEXPECTED READ!!! I caught up to the latest chapter in span of 4 days. That's how much of a page-turner and engaging it was. Love the protagonist, one of the cleverest I have read so far in a academy based webnovels.

Cliché and simple, nothing groundbreaking but it does a good job at the fundamentals. Overall, a good read that somehow hooked me into reading the whole thing in 2 days. There are some issues with POV switching and the power system for some. However, for more experienced readers this is definitely no issue.

(I've read way too many mtls so this is second nature)

Worldbuilding 8/10 (good worldbuilding)

Pacing 8/10 (nice and consistent pacing)

Plot 7/10 (quite simple but effective)

Characters 5/10 (other than the mc, the rest are not focused on and they don't show the backstory of most of the supporting characters and harem)

Concept 7/10 (the concept regarding norse and greek mythology is nice along with using the weapon names provides a nice little twist from the average transmigration wn)

Power System 8/10 (In general the power system is easy, 12 zodiacs that represent the strongest + his dad and some hidden villains, the pros such as Eden then knights which are decided on skill and aura)